Tyrese Haliburton struggled with his shooting touch but found other ways to impact the game.
Haliburton completed a crucial three-point play in overtime, sealing his first postseason triple-double.
Despite shooting woes, Haliburton contributed 18 points, 16 assists, and 10 rebounds.
Myles Turner delivered a playoff career-high 29 points to bolster the Pacers' victory.
Middleton's playoff career-high 42 points couldn't secure a win for the bruised Bucks
Damian Lillard added 28 points despite injuries, keeping the Bucks in contention